Should breakthrough infections change colleges’ fall plans?

by Joseph K. Clark

Dive Brief: 

  • Duke University reported more than 100 positive coronavirus cases in the week ending on Sunday, most of which were among vaccinated people, officials told a local media outlet. This makes North Carolina University one of the first examples of an institution with many vaccinated people testing positive for the virus this academic year.
  • According to health experts, these breakthrough infections aren’t a sign that vaccines don’t work; they continue to recommend combinations of vaccine, masking, and testing mandates on campuses.
  • Duke requires students and employees to prove they’ve been vaccinated or received an exemption before Monday classes start. The university administered almost 9,700 tests to around 7,800 students and employees during the week ending Sunday, with 111 positives for the coronavirus. That represents a 1.1% positivity rate.

Dive Insight: 

The highly contagious delta variant is causing coronavirus cases to surge throughout the U.S., though most new infections and hospitalizations are among unvaccinated people. In turn, colleges are reevaluating their safety measures for the fall.

While the pandemic has changed, the tools colleges should use haven’t. Health experts say schools should still use the mitigation measures they know work — including mask-wearing and coronavirus testing — and encourage or mandate the vaccines for people on campus.

According to Anita Barkin, co-chair of the American College Health Association’s COVID-19 task force, schools will likely see breakthrough infections on campuses. ACHA recommends that colleges mandate vaccines for all students on campus for the fall, where state law and resources allow.


Stanford University said seven fully vaccinated students died of symptomatic COVID-19 in July. A month later, the school said it would require all students to be tested regularly for the coronavirus regardless of their vaccination status.

Boston and Northeastern universities similarly announced in July they would periodically test students even if they were fully vaccinated.

Barkin stressed that breakthrough infections don’t mean the vaccines aren’t working. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention documents, the risk of contracting the coronavirus is eight times higher for unvaccinated people than for those who’ve gotten the shots. Their risk of hospitalization or death is 25 times higher.

The New York Times reported that fully vaccinated people only comprise 0.1% to 5% of those hospitalized with the coronavirus in states that track such data.

“It’s not a surprise that we see breakthrough infections,” said Gerald Parker Jr., associate dean for Global One Health at Texas A&M University’s veterinary medicine and biomedical sciences college. “Most of them, at least to date, are associated with mild and not severe diseases.”

Barkin said that even among vaccinated populations, periodic testing would be essential for colleges this fall. She applauded Duke for requiring the vaccine and having a “strong testing strategy.” The university tests all incoming students for the coronavirus and conducts weekly tests for students and employees.

Wastewater testing could also help, Parker said. Researchers recently found that the University of California, San Diego, has been screening wastewater for the coronavirus since the summer of 2020, enabling early detection of 85% of COVID-19 cases on campus.

However, due to state policies, some colleges won’t implement safety measures such as vaccine and mask mandates. That includes Texas, where the governor signed an executive order barring both coronavirus countermeasures by colleges and other public entities.

Health experts stressed that those colleges should focus on encouraging students to get the shots. “We need to have a reasoned discussion about the importance of vaccines and keep it out of the political domain,” Parker said.

Related Posts